ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Review: CrumplePop ToneGrade color correction plug-in

By Steve Douglas

Posted: 22 December 2011 12:00 AM
Last Update: 01 February 2012 07:42 AM

Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Steve Douglas

Review: CrumplePop’s "ToneGrade" Plug-in for Final Cut Pro X.
By Steve Douglas.

It was inevitable that third-party software companies would begin to update their plug-ins for Apple’s new Final Cut Pro X as soon as they could. Some already have, but with limited success, as adjustable parameters in previous sets are not always found in the Final Cut Pro X versions, and I have found that some are not as stable as they may have been in legacy versions of Final Cut Pro.

While CrumplePop has updated their split screen plug-in previously reviewed here and actually made improvements to it in that, for the Final Cut Pro X update, you can add color corrected clips to the many split screen options which will retain the color correction, this review will focus on CrumplePop’s completely new plug-in, ToneGrade for Final Cut Pro X.

There are some similarities to other plug-in packages on the market, but CrumplePop’s ToneGrade comes in at a fraction of the price of their competitors, is completely stable with Final Cut Pro X and offers many advantages in its simplicity of use, the diverse footage types it can be applied to, and how much it can improve your imaging results.

While I wouldn’t quite call ToneGrade a color grading application like Red Giant’s Magic Bullet Looks or a touch up app like Digital Anarchy’s Beauty Box, I would say that ToneGrade can provide you with the tools you need to make the subtle changes to your images color tone that can smooth out the wrinkles in skin or simply make your image pop just the little bit it needs to stand out.

In a nutshell, ToneGrade uses an image processing technique which simulates the properties of high dynamic range photography, quickly allowing you to dial in the small amounts of tone mapping to your image while expanding the details in both your highlights and shadows. Unlike full color grading applications which often soften or smear fine details, I found ToneGrade to be able to grade the image of my clips while retaining or even punching up the small details stylizing it for a greater dramatic appearance.

Above is the original photo while the photo below with ToneGrade applied brings a more dramatic look and depth to the image.

In Final Cut Pro X, ToneGrade, once installed, can be found in your effects browser under ‘Basics’. Scroll down to the bottom of your folder and ToneGrade will be there waiting for you to apply it as you would any effect in Final Cut X. Making sure your video inspector is open and set to Video, drag ToneGrade on to your clip. You will then see a short list of ToneGrade adjustable parameters for you to use. There are not too many so as to confuse or overwhelm you, but just what you need to accomplish the task at hand. We’ve all seen some effects parameters that really don’t accomplish a whole lot for the image. However, each one of the parameters provided in Tone Grade actually can make a huge difference.

Not too many, not too few; the parameters found in CrumplePop’s ToneGrade each has a productive purpose.

The first parameter, Depth, adjust the mid-tones and highlights. I found that, in its own way, it separates certain details from others creating just what it says, depth. At the same time it crushes shadows a bit, but you can use the depth slider or ToneGrade’s own Exposure slider to bring the blacks back up and balance out the image to your liking.

The Fine Detail slider does an excellent job on bringing up the smaller details like hair or, should you want it, the cragginess in an individual’s skin.

The top image is completely raw. The bottom shows how much improvement can be made by using CrumplePop’sToneGrade.

The Coarse Detail parameter is similar, but focuses more on the larger outline details. From my testing, this was the only parameter that should be used parsimoniously as bringing it up too much made the image look rough and somewhat cartoonish. Then again, any parameter adjustment to any plug-in should not be done to the extreme for a well graded and color corrected image.

The Shadow Depth setting further helps to avoid crushing the blacks too much maintaining details even in the darker areas of the image and worked quite nicely.

Top is the original frame. The green waters cloud out the image. On the image below, not only are details more defined but the diver really comes to the forefront.

The Saturation parameter works as any saturate/desaturate tool might work.

ToneGrade can be used to simply smooth out the wrinkles and blemishes to a face as well as sharpen details. The Skin Smoothing slider does just that; it helps smooth skin appearance out without creating a cartoon effect. Use it in small amounts to maintain realism.

Top image is the original photo and below is the adjusted version; slightly exaggerated for the purpose of this review, not only is there more detail in the hair and a sharpening of the overall image and note that wrinkles have been greatly reduced.

Both the Color Cool/Warm and Cool/Warm Intensity sliders adjust the overall tone of the image without effecting the image details. Drag the slider to the left for a cooler effect and to the right for a warmer look.

Top is the original photo. Wanting to warm the picture, bring more detail to her red hair and freckles and bring out her character, I used ToneGrade’s Warmth and Intensity sliders only slightly while bringing up the fine detail slider a bit as well.

Same image but dragged the sliders down to create a cooler image while maintaining details.

Usually I avoid using sliders as I don’t find them to be as precise as I like and wind up typing my settings in. Not sure why, but the sliders for ToneGrade were very easy to move about in Final Cut Pro X.

I found that just applying ToneGrade to a clip improved the image with its default settings. Below I applied ToneGrade to a clip of a Sand Tiger Shark on the wreck of the Spar in N. Carolina.

Original Frame.

ToneGrade is now applied with default settings. Notice an immediate improvement in color resolution as well as detail sharpness

Here we have the same image but with the Coarse Detail setting deliberately pushed up way too far. Only judicious use is necessary for this or any of the parameters.

Third party creation of plug-ins strictly developed for Final Cut Pro X was inevitable, and CrumplePop has produced the first plug-in devised only for Final Cut Pro X.

They are to be congratulated on doing a great job of it. Some real thought and effort have obviously gone into bringing this plug-in to the Final Cut Pro X community. On another note, I am known for frequently commenting on a company’s website and its user friendliness. As I have noted before, CrumplePop has always maintained excellently produced video tutorials for any of their plug-ins. The three separate video tutorial for ToneGrade were all well done and easily accessible. CrumplePop even has a couple of other plug-ins I didn’t know existed called ‘Paul Irmiter: Dacar set for light looks, and an interesting set of ‘Noir Moderne’ dramatic lighting effects. If their quality is as good as ToneGrade, I will have to check them out myself; soon.

CrumplePop’s ToneGrade plug-in for Final Cut Pro X was provided to the reviewer free of charge for the purpose of an objective review. In no way, is the reviewer obligated to provide either a positive or negative review. It is available to purchase from CrumplePop for $75.00.

Steve Douglas is a certified Apple Pro for Final Cut Pro 7 and underwater videographer. A winner of the 1999 Pacific Coast Underwater Film Competition, 2003 IVIE competition, 2004 Los Angeles Underwater Photographic competition, and the prestigious 2005 International Beneath the Sea Film Competition, where he also won the Stan Waterman Award for Excellence in Underwater Videography and 'Diver of the Year', Steve was a safety diver on the feature film "The Deep Blue Sea", contributed footage to the Seaworld Park's Atlantis production, and productions for National Geographic and the History channels. Steve was a feature writer for Asian Diver Magazine and is one of the founding organizers of the San Diego UnderSea Film Exhibition. He is available for both private and group seminars for Final Cut Pro and leads underwater filming expeditions and African safaris with upcoming excursions to the Cocos Islands, Costa Rica, and Hawaii. Feel free to contact him if you are interested in joining Steve on any of these exciting trips.

Review: Lightroom 3 for the Underwater Photographer :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Review: Lightroom 3 for the Underwater Photographer

Mike Veitch reviews Ocean Magic Productions new tutorial DVD.

Posted: 20 December 2011 03:24 AM
Last Update: 20 December 2011 03:49 AM
7 comment(s)
Categories: NewsReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Mike Veitch

Review: Lightroom 3 for the Underwater Photographer.
By Mike Veitch.

I can remember vividly the day I purchased a new D90 camera, and much to my dismay, realized that Photoshop CS2 could not read the files! What to do?! Well, I downloaded a trial version of Lightroom 2 that I had been reading about on Wetpixel and thought I would see if it worked. Sure enough, it read all my D90 files just fine and I was up and running again. However, after years of using Photoshop and Bridge I was a little lost about what I was doing in Lightroom and it took me a while to get a good workflow setup. What I needed at that time was an easy to follow “A-Z” of how to use Lightroom to get me going in the right direction. All I could find on the net were rather dry tutorials about areas in which I was confused or downloads of video tutorials that I couldn’t download due to my lousy internet connection in Indonesia. However, after watching and using Doug and Lorenza Sloss’ latest release “Lightroom 3 for the Underwater Photographer” I have discovered that what I really needed at that time was this disc. I have had several of Doug and Lorenza’s previous releases on how to use Photoshop and Bridge but this is the first “all in one” Lightroom tutorial that I have used and all I can say is “wow, why didn’t I have this before?” It could have saved me hours of frustration trying to find answers about simple things that aren’t necessarily intuitive in Lightroom itself. Simply put, this disc is an absolute must have for anyone who uses Lightroom, especially for those who are just discovering this great photography software and want to save hours of internet searches trying to figure out a reliable workflow.

Allow me to touch on a few of the highlights and a couple of nitpicks that I have about this presentation by Doug and Lorenza:

First, Doug has a funny sounding East Coast American accent that needs some getting used to ;)

The Layout:

At first glance, the layout can be a touch confusing as the “tab” for chapter navigation is on the left of the screen as opposed to on the top so I panicked a bit before finding it. However, once you click on the tab the entire menu navigation becomes easy as you please and any chapter can be clicked at any time. Therefore, if you want to start from the beginning simply click on the first “movie” and go from there or if you want to go to a specific tutorial hover over the number and a small preview shows you what tutorial is contained within. The menu is broken down into six sub sections and each section has a series of numbered tutorials ranging from a couple of minutes to over 10 minutes. Each chapter description is written on the back of the DVD case, but it would have made the layout simpler to navigate if each description on the disc cover had a number beside it corresponding to its number in the disc menu.

The Content:

The content is thoughtfully laid out and in the correct order that photographers will use Lightroom. Basically, Doug and Lorenza guide you through Lightroom from A-Z without going A to N to D to R to E to Z, therefore, it’s a great guide for people who are absolutely new to Lightroom. Starting with the Catalogue they then move into the Library Module, Develop Module, Exporting, Integration with Photoshop, and then into Sharing via slideshows and multimedia. This is exactly the workflow that most photographers will encompass when working with their own photos.

The tutorials are very easy to follow along as Doug uses a “dynamic cursor” to show exactly what and where the controls are while talking through the workflow. Doug’s speaking volume and rhythm are well controlled and improved from some of their earlier efforts. It’s easy to pause and rewind a tutorial to watch again or stop it while you follow along to what Doug is doing in the tutorial. Unlike an online tutorial, there is no buffering and reloading the video, it’s simply start and stop to your heart's content. What makes this tutorial relevant to underwater photographers is that Doug uses underwater photos as his examples and he discusses the specific issues that plague us. With general Lightroom tutorials, there are no examples of getting rid of unsightly backscatter or dealing with blue tints and hues that are common in underwater photography. By showing samples of both macro and wide-angle scenes, Doug really brings to light what we can do with this program in conjunction with our very specialized field.

As a fairly experienced Lightroom user, I found that I learned a lot from many of the videos especially for things such as keyboard shortcuts, using Collections, User Presets and Templates, Masks, and other time-saving options that can be used within Lightroom but aren’t necessarily easy to figure out on your own. Another key tutorial for me was the Printing discussion; I have never been able to get consistent results from printing my own photos. Doug walks through printing from beginning to end and the test prints I made came out perfectly without having to leave Lightroom.

I can’t really find any negatives to write about the product as it is exactly what it professes to be: A guide to understanding the Lightroom workflow aimed at underwater photographers. For folks who are new to Lightroom or have only explored it a little bit, these tutorials are absolutely essential to create an efficient workflow. For folks who are fairly experienced with Lightroom there is also a lot of good information contained within that can optimize workflow time. One of the most important tutorials covered is right at the beginning and deals with backing up and exporting the Lightroom catalogue. I bet a lot of folks out there who use Lightroom on a daily basis don’t back up their catalogue often enough or even understand what that means, so watching that video alone may be worth the purchase of this disc!

The copy of Lightroom 3 for the Underwater Photographer used by the reviewer for the review was provided free of charge by the Ocean Magic Productions. It is available via their website at a retail price of $99.

About the author: Originally from Vancouver, B.C., Canada, Wetpixel moderator Mike Veitch is a professional underwater photographer and trip leader. After spending many years working on boats and resorts in the Indo-Pacific region, Mike has settled in Indonesia where he spends his time photographing the worlds richest marine bio-system and conducting photography workshops and leading trips throughout the country. For more information please visit his website.

Review: Divergent Media ClipWrap :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Review: Divergent Media ClipWrap

By Steve Douglas

Posted: 16 November 2011 01:00 PM
Last Update: 16 November 2011 01:14 PM
6 comment(s)
Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Steve Douglas

Review: ClipWrap.
By Steve Douglas.

Normally when given a video file that needed converting or transcoding before ingesting into Final Cut Pro I went to my old standby, MPEG Streamclip, a free downloadable application that has always worked for most everything I threw at it.

This time, the MTS files given to me by a client wouldn't even be accepted by MPEG Streamclip. What to do? I then tried Red Giant's Magic Bullet Grinder, another excellent transcoding application, and the MTS file still could not be opened. Bottom line was that MTS and M2T files are not directly playable on Macs but they do contain media that Macs can play, both MPEG-2 and H.264. I was stuck, until I remembered that I was sent Divergent Media's 'ClipWrap' a few months ago. I hadn't had the chance to install and test it out and here was the perfect opportunity presenting itself. In the back of my mind I was thinking that if MPEG Streamclip couldn't do it, then I doubted that ClipWrap would. Boy, was I wrong!

ClipWrap is a Mac only application designed to make an HDV or AVCHD file compatible with your NLE application whether it be Final Cut Pro, iMovie, Avid, or Adobe Premier Pro. A great many of today's camcorders record to a variety of media types whether they be to hard-disk, Compact Flash or SD cards. These transport files tend not to be suited well for post production, especially on a Mac. I've learned that no one size or application fits all. This is where ClipWrap comes in to save the day.

ClipWrap works by unlocking that content and rewrapping the file into a standard Quicktime file. The download and installation was a simple and typical process as was registering my serial number. There is no learning curve when using ClipWrap. It is as intuitive as any application can be. It opens as a single window where you can then drag your existing MTS, M2t, or M2ts files. Alternatively, you can click the plus sign at the lower left of the window to search for a file and add it, or use the minus symbol to delete a file that you have already brought into the window.

Once installed I opened the application and dragged the MTS file over to ClipWrap window. It immediately took the file and waited for my instructions. I set the destination where I wanted the converted file to be, clicked on the ‘Convert’ button and that was all I needed to do.

While ClipWrap is not, at its origin, meant to transcode files, it is perfectly capable of doing so without generational loss. ClipWrap works very fast. ‘Blazing’ is a better term for it as a 20 second MTS file took 1 second to re-wrap into QT H.264 and 16 seconds to rewrap and transcode to Pro Res 422. You can stack several files at once and either watch the process bar proceed or get yourself a speedy cup of java. Additionally, clicking on the disclosure triangle next to each file will display much of the metadata associated with the clip.

‘Rewrap’ in the Output Format section of the ClipWrap window is the default setting which will convert the MTS file to Quicktime. However, if you wish to transcode the file at the same time, you are given several codec choices to choose from. Select one and click on the ‘Convert’ button.

ClipWrap's preferences are plain and simple without the need for many alterations. Updates are automatic though there is a 'check for updates' under its file menu. As shown below, there is also the opportunity to have the converted files open in your NLE or Quicktime wrapper of choice. It would be my recommendation to set your destination in ClipWrap to your project's capture scratch folder. Once rewrapping and transcoding is complete, I would then suggest that you open Final Cut Pro and import the files you converted in ClipWrap.

Within the Audio Preferences you have the choice between creating either a Stereo or Multichannel Output for 5.1 surround audio. By default, ClipWrap will convert AC-3 5.1 channel surround sound audio into 6 discrete channels of audio. This allows you to have complete control over your audio layout. However, if you are editing in an older application, or are mixing 5.1 audio with more traditional stereo audio, you may wish to convert your 5.1 audio to 2 channel stereo.

For those working with AVCHD camcorders producing MTS files, you can either import these files individually to ClipWrap or bring in the BDMV folder in its entirety. Because many of these AVCHD camcorders have recording file size limits, the camcorders will create multiple files to work around this limitation. These files then need to be rejoined during a rewrap or transcode so that playback is free from any glitches. Since AVCHD camcorders number their files sequentially, ClipWrap will parse the metadata from the camera to determine clip spanning and join them as one.

In this day of expensive applications and 3rd party plug ins that are often used infrequently, it is nice to find an application that not only is very inexpensive but, with the advent of more camcorders creating files not conducive to Macs, an app that really can save the day for both you and your client. In my opinion, both thumbs up for ClipWrap. It saved my day.

ClipWrap is available from Divergent Media priced at $49.95. Steve was provided with the software free of charge by Divergent Media for the review.

About the author: Steve Douglas is a certified Apple Pro for Final Cut Pro 7 and underwater videographer. A winner of the 1999 Pacific Coast Underwater Film Competition, 2003 IVIE competition, 2004 Los Angeles Underwater Photographic competition, the prestigious 2005 International Beneath the Sea Film Competition where he also won the Stan Waterman Award for Excellence in Underwater Videography and "Diver of the Year". Steve was a safety diver on the feature film "The Deep Blue Sea", contributed footage to the Seaworld Park's Atlantis production, and productions for National Geographic and the History channels. Steve was also a feature writer for Asian Diver Magazine and is one of the founding organizers of the San Diego UnderSea Film Exhibition. He is available for both private and group seminars for Final Cut Pro and leads underwater filming expeditions and African safaris with upcoming excursions to the Maldives and Raja Ampat. Feel free to contact him if you are interested in joining Steve on any of these exciting trips.

Review: Digital Film Tools Photocopy plug-in :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Review: Digital Film Tools Photocopy plug-in

By Drew Wohl

Posted: 10 April 2011 12:39 PM
Last Update: 10 April 2011 12:55 PM
1 comment(s)
Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Drew Wohl ( TheRealDrew )

Review: Digital Film Tools Photocopy.
By Drew Wohl.

Introduction:

I admit that I am somewhat of a plug-in junkie when using Photoshop, Final Cut or other software. I guess it goes back to the early days of Photoshop and Kai's Power Tools.

Over time Photoshop and other software has evolved and effects became easier to do but it does not mean a good plug-in does not have a place in the toolbox. A good plug-in can save you time and can even inspire you as you dial in various settings to see things you may not have seen before.

When I was told about Photocopy by Digital Film Tools I took a look at some examples they had posted at their site. It looked impressive. And fun.

The folks at Digital Film Tools went through well-known movies (94), paintings (72), photographs (40) and processes such as Cyanotype (30), analyzed them in terms of brightness, color, tone, detail, grain and texture and placed them into a plug-in which contains over 200 presets.

Even better, Photocopy can be used for stills or video. On the stills side, Photocopy works with Adobe Photoshop, Adobe Photoshop Elements, Adobe Photoshop, Lightroom and Apple Aperture (one photo license will run Photocopy with all of these on the same machine) and on the video side, Photocopy works with Adobe After Effects, Apple Final Cut Pro and Avid Editing Systems (a separate video license is needed for this).

The specific requirements are as follows:

  • Adobe Photoshop CS3 and up.
  • Adobe Photoshop Elements 6 and up.
  • Photoshop Lightroom 3 and up.
  • Apple Aperture 3 and up.

  • After Effects CS3 and up.

  • Final Cut Pro 6 and up.
  • Avid Symphony, Media Composer, Newscutter, Xpress Pro.

  • Macintosh Multicore Intel® processor.

  • Mac OSX 10.5.x - OSX 10.6.x.

  • Windows XP, Windows Vista, Windows 7.

I was sent two licenses, one for stills and and one for video. The installation was quick and easy: Download the package, click install, enter the key and that was pretty much it. The included manuals are easy to read and show you everything. The software, however, is so intuitive that I did not need the manuals to get up and running.

Photo Applications:

PhotoCopy is quick to launch and there is a short video below showing the process in real time.

The steps for photo applications:

Select the photo you would like to work on.

Select Edit In PhotoCopy In Aperture:

In Lightroom:

In Photoshop:

PhotoCopy launches and you will see the following screen. On the left hand side are all the presets, broken down by general category. To the right are parameter sliders to adjust the presets.

Left hand side presets:

Right hand side adjustment sliders

Pick a preset and adjust to taste and use the up and down arrows on the keyboard to scroll through presets to quickly see how an effect will generally look. Like any set of effects, one particular preset may not work well with a particular still and you can get a quick sense of which will work or not.

PhotoCopy was quick and responsive when scrolling through images from a Canon 5D Mark II on a 2 x 2.93 Ghz Quad-Core Mac. When adjusting the sliders there was a brief blurring of some part of the images (similar to when loading an image in Lightroom for example when it needs to build a preview) but it was quicker than Lightroom or Aperture by a good margin.

When you are done you have a few options: You can save whatever tweaks you made to the presets as your own customized preset by pressing the icon with the question mark located in the parameters section. These presets later show up in the custom tab. (Settings that I had saved in the photo applications were also available in the video applications.)

You can also save the image by pressing the gear icon above the presets. The image is processed, which is done fairly quickly, and the processed image is sent back to the photo application you are using and PhotoCopy closes.

Another feature in PhotoCopy is making your own presets from scratch: In the PhotoCopy window select Create Preset

Then a split screen comes up. In the example below I used a section of the feathers to create a texture.

I created another one using a section of the wood

One thing to note is that I had crashes and hangs if I did not save the image and/or did not close out PhotoCopy prior to sending another image to PhotoCopy. I did not check the manual as to whether there was a mention of this as part of the workflow. It is a minor issue, and probably the only nitpick I have. Once figuring this part out, it was not a practical problem.

A couple of other things to note. First, duplicate layers in Photoshop and send a layer out to PhotoCopy. The original stays the same and the new layer will be the one processed. The second is that PhotoCopy does not work on RAW images. The images will be sent as Photoshop PSD or TIFF files and there are options with these for Color Space and Bit Depth.

The following video shows the entire process, including scrolling through presets, applying changes and sending the photo back to Lightroom. The video is playing in real time. It took just about two minutes to send a photo out, run through about 2 dozen presets or so, tweak the one I wanted a bit, process the image and have it back in Lightroom.

Video Applications:

Using PhotoCopy in After Effects and Final Cut is very similar to using it in photo applications.

You apply the filter.

In After Effects:

In Final Cut:

Which results in the filters showing up as follows:

In After Effects:

In Final Cut:

Selecting the preset drop down in After Effects or Load in Final Cut opens up a dialog to make the selection of a preset, while adjustments, and saving custom presets, are done in After Effects or Final Cut with the parameters shown above.

In After Effects the PhotoCopy filter did not slow down playback any more than what I normally find in After Effects and in Final Cut rendering was required.

Conclusion:

As mentioned earlier, not all of the presets will work well with every photo or video clip. But that is no different than any other set of plug-in effects. Some can produce banding in stills. Some of the presets may not be applicable at all to underwater photos or video. But I quickly found many favorites that I would use for photos and video. The ease and interface of PhotoCopy make it a pleasure to work with and ultimately it is a nice plug-in to have on hand.

Digital Film Tools offers fully functional versions PhotoCopy (15 day time limit), together with the manuals, on their site

It is worthwhile to try it out. Make sure to have an idea of which photos or video that you want to work with ahead of time so you can really put the software through the paces to see what it can do.

Review: Eizo CG245W Self-Calibrating Computer Monitor :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Review: Eizo CG245W Self-Calibrating Computer Monitor

By Steve Douglas

Posted: 08 March 2011 01:56 PM
Last Update: 08 March 2011 03:15 PM

Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Steve Douglas

Review: Eizo CG245W Self-Calibrating Computer Monitor.
Review by Steve Douglas.

Using a good computer monitor is, without a doubt, essential to any editor. Not all monitors are made the same, have the same colorations, and are capable of presenting an image the way it should be. The larger screen size of any monitor can provide more workspace than its smaller counterparts, true, but it is the monitor’s reaction time, resolution and pixel pitch that differentiates the needs of the text based user from the more demanding needs of the photographer and videographers.

The Eizo ColorEdge CG245W is a 24.1” monitor aimed for use by editing and graphics professionals working with both still or moving images. It is designed and constructed solely by Eizo and nothing is outsourced so that all quality control and testing is done "in-house."

The CG245W monitor weighs in at a not too heavy 22.3 lb. including the stand. It was delivered in a well packaged box constructed and designed to protect from any shipping drops. I have been amazed at some of the poor shipping practices by some companies but that is not the case here. Opening the main container you have a long, flat box containing the instructions, a disc with the manual and software and the sections of the shading hood for either horizontal or vertical monitor setup. A monitor cleaning kit is also included. Lift that box out of the main container and the monitor was well cushioned by fitted Styrofoam protectors.

I was impressed by the circular base of the stand which functions in the same way that a ‘lazy Susan’ might. You can easily swivel the monitor either left or right, raise or lower the stand or tilt the monitor to your preferences. At the same time, the outer portion of the stand has a hard rubber ring which prevents the monitor and stand from sliding on your editing bay desktop. There is a solid stability to it. The vertical section of the stand is what enables you to slide the monitor up or down and while it works just fine, there is a cheapness to the plastic that is used. One small part of the lower tilt section in the back of the monitor popped off and I was able to ascertain that this was no high-grade plastic. After fumbling with it a few times I was able to insert it back in place and have had no problems since. The stand also provides a cable protection and confining box which really is quite useful. Just thread your cable into the opening of the box and things look neat and straight. A lot better than the spider network of cables I usually have had to look at.

The monitor comes supplied with dual DVI-I inputs which accepts both digital and analogue signals and a single display port terminal cable which can carry both audio and video. However, the monitor does not have its own speakers. On the upper left of the monitor are two USB 2.0 ports as well. My wired keyboard went into one and a scanner cable into the other.

What initially piqued my interest was the Eizo monitor’s ability to self calibrate either at the users discretion or by a programmed schedule over the course of the month or year. The Eizo Monitor has a unique sensor built-in and hidden from view within the top of the monitor. When calibrating, this sensor, which is about the size of thumb-drive, swings down to perform the calibration of the monitor’s brightness, gain, gray balance and color. The sensor is made using Eizo’s high-precision professional spectroradiometers to calibrate the sensor for brightness and color chromaticity and are adjusted individually to the LCD panel at the time of shipping from the factory. Since there will always be a variability between LCD panels, this final individual adjustments assures the accuracy of the sensor. This is done by measuring the R, G, and B gamma values from 0 – 1,023 (with 10-bit input) and then using the monitor’s 12-bit look-up table to select the 1,024 most appropriate tones* to achieve the desired value.

The CG245W has a DUE (Digital Uniformity Equalizer) function which significantly improves uniformity characteristics relative to other existing models. To reduce the effect of the edges of the sensor upon the measurement, the edges of the sensor are not used in the measurement when it swings down by 90 degrees.

The sensor itself does not correct uniformity. Since the sensor is at the perimeter of the screen, it can be easily influenced by the uniformity. To minimize this, Eizo correlates the center and the perimeter of the screen at the factory.

There are three software apps that are installed by way of the included disc. All three can be found installed in your Utilities folder. The first is the Color Navigator Agent whose icon sits in your dock and changes from blue to red when the number of hours between calibration that you have specified has passed. You can also use it to change profiles by simply right clicking on it in the dock and choosing from your list of saved profiles. Finally, should you decide to change the monitor's resolution using a 3rd party calibration software other than Eizo's own Color Navigator, a pop up window will appear confirming that this is something you really want to do.

The second is the 'Correlation Utility' which can be used when other Eizo Color Edge monitors are used in the same work environment and it is necessary to correlate the CG245W to the calibration results off a third-party device.

The ColorNavigator Agent is found installed into your utilities folder and runs continually, though you can disable it if you wish. It is this utility that monitors the light your monitor is being exposed to. It disables itself when you are using the ColorNavigator and re-enables itself when you are done.

The third utility, and the one you will actually be using to calibrate your Eizo monitor, is the ColorNavigator, also found in the Utilities folder. For updates to either the software or firmware there are no ‘Check for Updates’ buttons in the software’s preferences. There should be and I have been told that they will be including an Auto Software Update in the next ColorNavigator revision due out in May. In the meantime, Eizo does have a downloads page on their website so that you can check on the version numbers. I was told that you can also subscribe to their newsletter, which would inform you of any updates but it will not be up on their website until the end of the month. Or, you can subscribe by sending them an email.

The good news is that employing the ColorNavigator is a piece of cake.

The three applications found in your Utilities folder.

Once your monitor has warmed up for about 30 minutes be sure that your screen saver has been disabled, so that it doesn’t pop on during the calibration process. Be sure that all other applications have been closed before continuing . Time to begin the calibration process.

Clicking on the Color Navigator directs you to the first window asking you to select which device you want to be calibrated.

You can disable this first window though it would be useful if you had multiple monitors hooked up. In the Color Navigator’s preferences, under the ‘measurement device’ tab, there is a ‘multiple monitor matching’ setting for those using dual Eizo monitors.

Now we get down to business by selecting the mode of calibration you are looking for. You have a choice between the Graphic Design and Photography modes and the Printing mode. Just click next and you are on to the next step.

The next window to come up gives you some smart reminders. If you hadn’t already, you are warned to close all other applications and to adjust the rooms light to the lighting you most normally work in. Clicking on Proceed brings you closer to the actual calibration.

It takes only a few minutes to complete the calibration and is actually interesting to watch as it goes through it paces with different colored swatches coming on-screen behind the drop down sensor. The whole process took but a couple of minutes.

The progress bars that appear on the lower right hand of the monitor during calibration indicate not only the progress but what is being calibrated be it the brightness, gain or color.

Once completed you are presented a window representing the numerical results of your current calibration.

The final results on the left and, should you click on ‘Validate Profile,’ the more specific settings come up as shown on the right. After validation, the number of the measured color patch, the color patch, the RGB values, the measurement results, the calculated value derived from the profile, and the color difference (delta-E) between the profile and the measurement results are shown on the result window. Clicking on ‘Save’ brings you this one final message advising you to avoid making manual changes via the controls on the lower frame of the monitor screen.

Viola, your monitor is now properly calibrated and the profile is integrated into a ColorSync managed workflow.

You can also set the ColorNavigator to schedule self-calibration on a regular basis, during the middle of the night for example, even if the Mac itself is shut down.

Naturally, if you chose to calibrate the Eizo CG245W manually you have full access to do so through the many backlit and unobtrusive buttons along the lower front of the monitor.

These buttons will be ‘locked’ should you have ColorNavigator up and running. If using the self calibration mode, you may never need to employ them.

Should you make an error while manually adjusting any of the monitor’s settings, the Reset button may come in quite handy.

I have always been of the belief that a monitor needed to have a burn in period of around 150 hours before a proper calibration can be done. However, in speaking with Eizo’s support representative, he states that this is not necessary for the Eizo CG245W. Because precise calibration is done at the factory prior to shipping, as well as Eizo’s Auto Aging function, which works in the background measuring the aging condition of the monitor and adjusts appearance accordingly, a burn in time becomes superfluous.

The 24 in, 1920 x 1200-pixel display claims to show 98% of the Adobe RGB color space which, for professional work, is pretty darn great. The IPS LCD panel has an excellent viewing angle from either side when the hood is unattached. With the hood attached, your view is then limited a touch but nothing to complain about, especially since the monitor rotates so precisely on its stand.

The hood for shielding the display from stray light and to help keep your image color consistent was a bit of a pain to install. The directions for setting it up are plain horrible as none of the pieces are coded or marked and the ‘instruction’ (sic) sheet reminds me of the worst of Xmas toy directives. I was never much good at jigsaw puzzles. Eventually, I figured it out on my own but even then, I have noticed that accidentally touching the side panels moves the panel out of the tiny slot on the side of the monitor that is supposed to hold it in. Once secured, if left alone, all is fine; just try not to move the monitor by the hood and avoid any accidental pushes of it.

Thankfully, the Eizo monitor is a non-glare LCD. While a glossy screen may deliver vivid color and rich black tones with high contrast ratios, they also blatantly reflect indoor lighting and the user’s reflection which can cause eyestrain and viewer distraction. Additionally, glossy screens can be more easily scratched and be damaged by chemical cleaners. While most editors prefer a non glare screen, not all are created equal and the non-glare LCD of the Eizo monitor is the best I have yet to see displaying no reflection even though it is evening as I write this with my office lights full on. While the vibrancy of colors might not seem as great as the glossy screen, since I use an external monitor for color correction, as we all should, this becomes a lesser point to pick.

While contrast, brightness and resolution are all important characteristics of when searching for a new monitor, attention should also be paid to the monitor’s pixel pitch. All monitors display text, photos and video via the creation of very small dots of color. These dots, or pixels, will vary in shade and intensity as defined by the image. On a CRT monitor the pixel is created via electron beams exciting electrons on a phosphorescent coated glass. On a LCD monitor pixels are created by small diodes that mimic how a CRT creates an image. The important factor in this is determined by the Pixel Pitch. The smaller the pitch, the sharper the image which helps reduce eyestrain, but, also, is a major aesthetic consideration. A dot pitch of .31 or less provides a sharp image, especially on text.The best computer monitors will have a pixel pitch whose maximum is .28. The Eizo CG245W has a pixel pitch of .27 falling nicely into what a monitor of this caliber should be.

Do not confuse a computer monitor’s pixel pitch with that of a large screen television whose pixel pitch may be much higher, but because you are viewing it from a considerably greater distance, all looks well.

So what makes the Eizo CG245W monitor worth it's not inexpensive cost? I love that it’s sensor is surely far more accurate than my own aging eyes and that I can easily set the calibration either on my whim or by scheduled times. It is not a gimmick; the Eizo monitor delivers true hardware calibration resulting in more color accurate and precise imaging. More important than my personal opinions are the facts. While the Apple Cinema Display and many other monitors on the market try to achieve 92% of the Adobe RGB, the Eizo CG245W ColorEdge series monitor, with its proprietary sensor achieves 98% of the Adobe RGB which translates into a wider color gamut and coverage.

Color gamut comparison between sRGB and Adobe RGB.

Thus, you will see a more accurate expression of colors not just in green but high in chroma saturation like cyan, yellow and orange which cannot be expressed in the sRGB color gamut. Add that to the complete digital uniformity of the CG245W monitor from edge to edge, a power save mode that should save you a bit of cash during its use and a 5 year warranty and you have one expensive but highly accurate monitor which should greatly pay off in the long run for yourself and your client’s greater satisfaction.

The Eizo CG245W Self-Calibrating Computer Monitor costs $2989.00. For more details and technical specifications please see the Eizo website.

This review is by Steve Douglas, a certified Apple Pro for Final Cut Pro 7 and underwater videographer. A winner of the 1999 Pacific Coast Underwater Film Competition, 2003 IVIE competition, 2004 Los Angeles Underwater Photographic competition, and the prestigious 2005 International Beneath the Sea Film Competition, where he also won the Stan Waterman Award for Excellence in Underwater Videography and 'Diver of the Year', Steve was a safety diver on the feature film "The Deep Blue Sea", contributed footage to the Seaworld Park's Atlantis production, and productions for National Geographic and the History channels. Steve was a feature writer for Asian Diver Magazine and is one of the founding organizers of the San Diego UnderSea Film Exhibition.

Review: Nik Software Silver Efex 2 :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Review: Nik Software Silver Efex 2

Industry standard black and white processing software

Posted: 06 March 2011 01:20 PM
Last Update: 06 March 2011 01:50 PM

Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Adam Hanlon ( adamhanlon )
Related Link: Nik Software

Review: Nik Software Silver Efex 2.
By Adam Hanlon.

Most pro photographers use different techniques, software or workflows to meet their creative objectives. However, when talking about black and white or mono conversions, there seems to be a degree of unanimity. Although most image processing software has mono options, if you pick most of the mono images you see around and ask how they were processed, the majority of answers will include reference to Nik Software Silver Efex Pro.

Silver Efex Pro is a plug-in that sits within Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop or Apple Aperture. Once opened from within these it opens into a stand-alone application. Silver Efex Pro uses Nik's U Point technology, similar to that used in Nikon Capture NX2. I find this a very intuitive method of applying local corrections. The software aims to give an all-in-one mono workflow, with overall image improvements, image presets, smart filters, a grain engine and film emulations.

The recent release of Silver Efex Pro version 2 has prompted a review of its new features and performance. Key differences between it and version 1 are:

Intuitive History Browser.

The history browser allows the user to move forwards and backwards through various adjustments.

Structure and Fine Structure.

Typical contrast adjustments enhance lights and darks along edges. Structure control works more precisely "between" the edges to enhance images, working in concert with contrast. Silver Efex Pro 2 has a Fine Structure control that brings out more visible detail in the smallest structures, details, and textures of an image without creating an over-sharpened look.

Soft Contrast.

Soft Contrast adds contrast to an image by applying contrast to different areas of the image in a dynamic way.

GPU Processing.

Silver Efex Pro 2 has multi-threaded 64-bit GPU processing.

Dynamic Brightness.

Dynamic Brightness ensures that different areas of the image receive different brightening adjustments, based on tonal values of each area. By moving one slider, dark areas get brighter all without affecting lighter objects in your image and vice-versa.

Natural Image Borders.

Silver Efex Pro 2 has a new set of intelligent algorithms that incorporate organic elements to create unique, natural, and random image borders. These are fully customizable.

Specially Developed Algorithms.

The software has been developed so that each part works intelligently together with others for the best results possible. Rather than algorithms working in isolation, each algorithm intelligently changes contrast relationships between colors and other related algorithms as they are adjusted.

Amplify Blacks and Whites.

Accentuates blacks and whites for greater impact by increasing their presence.

Selective Color.

The selective color tool enables the addition of color elements back into images. It utilizes U Point technology to select objects without creating complicated selections or layer masks.

I installed the trial version of Silver Efex Pro 2 onto my 15" Macbook Pro and my Mac Pro. I have utilized the option to integrate it into Lightroom, as this is the program I use for image editing more than any other, although I also also installed it into Photoshop and Aperture for comparison purposes. I have used Silver Efex Pro 1 on both machines in the past.

Installation is, predictably, easy and the user interface integrates smoothly with the parent software applications. In Lightroom, Silver Efex 2 is selected via the drop down menu accessed by control/right clicking on the image/s.

Lightroom menu give access to Silver Efex Pro 2.

This then open the image within the Silver Efex Pro 2 interface:

The Silver Efex Pro 2 interface.

The interface opens with the image in mono in a neutral preset, and good starting point is to scroll through the 38 (compared with 29 in Version 1) supplied presets to see if they match the desired creative outcome. There is also the option of creating new presets via the custom button, importing presets, or adding custom settings as new preset.

Once I have a preset that I am comfortable with, I can adjust individual image settings via the left hand panel. These initially adjust general brightness, contrast and structure, before moving into localised adjustments using control points on the image.

Preset, history and adjustment menu tabs.

Adding a control point allows for adjustment of brightness, contrast and structure within a limited area of the image. New in Silver Efex Pro 2 is the ability to add control points to:

  1. Amplify Whites. This increases the highlights in the area selected.
  2. Amplify Blacks. This increases the shadows in the area selected.
  3. Fine Structure. This increases the fine details in the area selected.
  4. Selective Colorization. This returns the colors in the area or selected object to their original tone.

Control point selector and menu.

Moving on through the adjustment tab is the ability to add a color filter and then the film types panel. This gives the ability to add grain, adjustable for size and hardness, and to adjust color sensitivity, levels and curves.

Lastly is the finishing adjustments tab. Image tone, edge burning and vignette are all controllable here, as is the new add borders feature. This gives access to 14 different border types, all co-ordinated with the previous settings in terms of tone and color.

The tab also has a loupe or histogram that can be toggled. The main window also offers differing viewing options including with only one tab open:

Or as a split screen comparison view among others:

In use, I find the Silver Efex Pro interface intuitive and relatively simple to use. It is very feature-rich and has enough control and adjustment to satisfy the most demanding of users. Alternatively, and I must admit I fall into this category, it allows for a quick and easy workflow to get great results in mono quickly. In the era of film photography, color filters were used extensively to get pleasing mono effects, and in my experience, Silver Efex Pro is currently the only package that replicates those effects. Despite the relative ease of conversion from color to mono in the digital era, to get excellent results, a straightforward conversion is rarely satisfying.

Version 2 of the software takes this level of control to another level. Selective color in particular can give a eye-catching visual effect. The interface is definitely improved with the addition of a history panel. Many of the other new features are "under the hood" and it may be that their benefits will become more obviously valuable in time. It is also a factor that with so many adjustments, it is likely that the user may use many of them very seldom, although, of course, when you do its effect will be dramatic.

With my computers, I did not find Version 2 to be significantly faster than version 1. Both operate at a very good speed, even with large .tiff files.

There is no doubt in my mind that Silver Efex Pro 2 will give mono effects unlike any other current software solution. If you enjoy black and white images then this is an elegant and sophisticated program that achieves great results.

If you already own Silver Efex Pro 1, the decision of whether to upgrade or not is more difficult. I think this is probably best decided by assessing whether you need the additional creative features in it or not. In my case, the ability to add selective color for creative effect has ensured that I will be upgrading.

Silver Efex Pro version 2 is available as a download or boxed product from Nik Software at $199.95 for the full program or $99.95 as an upgrade from version 1. There is a 15 day fully-featured trial available. The software is also available from re-sellers worldwide. This review was carried out on the demo version.

Review: RE:Vision Effects Twixtor version 5 :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Review: RE:Vision Effects Twixtor version 5

By Steve Douglas

Posted: 27 December 2010 07:39 AM
Last Update: 05 January 2011 01:10 PM

Categories: NewsReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Steve Douglas
Related Link: RE:Vision Effects

Review: RE:Vision Effects Twixtor FCP plug-in version 5.
By Steve Douglas.

To be completely honest I received Twixtor version 4 a few years ago. Unfortunately, I was so busy with traveling demands, reviews and projects that I never even got around to installing and using it. It wasn’t until I was at a meeting where the discussion led to time remapping that Re:Vision’s Twixtor came to the forefront of the conversation and several attendees asked whether I could do a demo of it. I went home and found my installer license for Version 4 only to realize that a new version, Version 5, one that was compatible with both Final Cut Pro and Adobe’s CS5 was available. Like any application or plug in you might have, if you haven’t used it in a long time, boning up on how to use them to your advantage is and was completely necessary.

Twixtor does for time remapping whether for slow motion or speed remapping footage what the new time remapping functions in Final Cut Studio aspires to. This is not to say the Final Cut’s speed tools were not improved in Studio 3 but, from what I can see and test, it does not perform quite as well as Re:Vision’s Twixtor. At the same time, Twixtor can be a bit more complicated to utilize than the ‘speed tool’ features found in Final Cut Pro.

This is primarily because Final Cut Pro doesn’t allow for clip duration changes created by 3rd party plug-ins like Re:Vision’s Twixtor. In Final Cut Pro, when using its own speed adjustments, if you double the speed of a clip, the duration of that clip will be 1/2 the duration of the original clip. Conversely, should you slow down a clip by 50% using the Final Cut speed feature, the clip will double in duration. For a 3rd party plug-in like Twixtor, you must work around the limitation that prevents changing the duration of any clip whether you are creating a slow or fast motion effect.

All the settings you need to create slow motion or speeded effects are contained in the Twixtor plug in. The Twixtor Pro plug-in has many more parameters for you to work with.

Speeding up a clip by a specific percentage is quite easy. In the Twixtor parameters found in the Viewer’s Filter’s tab, you need only to adjust the percentage of the clip found under the filter’s Output Control with the Time Remap Mode’s drop-down menu set to ‘speed’. If you want the clip to be twice as fast, you would set it at 200%. Because the duration of the clip with Twixtor applied cannot be changed, once the clip is rendered and played back, the part of the duration that under Final Cut would have been shortened, will play back as black. This is simple to deal with as all you need do is find the last good frame of the sped up clip and use the blade tool to cut the unwanted black portion of the clip.

The sped up clip, once rendered, will display many black frames that take the place of duration of the original clip. Finding the last good frame and blading off the black is a piece of cake.

If you need to time remap a clip’s speed by specific frames that is also possible. However, keep in mind that if you are altering the speed of clip using frames, you should change the time code display to the right of the RT drop-down menu to frames, and knowing exactly which frame your clip begins on and each frame number where you intend to change the speed is imperative. The other, and easier, alternative is to do your speed ramping by simply key framing the percentages of your Twixtor placed clip.

Most editors are used to working in a time-code mode as shown here.

By right clicking in the space between the time-code window and the sequence you can change the mode to a ‘frames’ configuration.

Creating a slow motion effect is a bit more complicated than simply adjusting speed. Again, this is because of Final Cut’s not allowing plug-ins to affect the duration of the original clip. This is done by placing the clip whose duration you wish to alter in a new sequence. You then duplicate that sequence into a new sequence two or three times. Create another new sequence and drag this extended sequence into it. Now you can apply the Twixtor plug-in. If you attempt to double-click on the extended sequence in order to bring up the Twixtor parameters in the Viewer, you will only get the original nested sequence. This is not much of a problem as you need only go up the Final Cut’s View/ Sequence and now the Twixtor parameters will show up for you to adjust. Keep in mind that any time you use Twixtor you must render in order to see the results. This can be a bit of a pain as you tweak your effect with any of the parameters after the initial render. Re rendering will always be necessary.

The final results of any plug-in are usually the most important aspect to consider. In Twixtor’s case, for most footage, the results can be gorgeous. I found it best, when creating any slow motion work to use clips where there was not a whole lot of motion in the first place. For example, below is a frame of a large jellyfish with many small tentacles. This clip was slowed down to 20% and the slow motion was beautiful to look at.

Notice that even the smallest tentacle retains its appearance without blur or ghosting of the image.

With very fast motion I could not eliminate blurring of the image. This is understandable as when a smaller object is moving this fast, even capturing a single un-blurred frame is difficult.

This frame of a cheetah chasing down a wildebeest has had no speed tools placed upon it. It is the original frame.

This is the same frame but with Final Cut Pro’s speed tool used to slow it down to 25%. You can see ghosting of the animals quite clearly.

Using Twixtor on this frame doesn’t eliminate the ghosting but there is definite improvement in the image.

Conversely, this larger subject moving relatively slowly over my head, when slowed down to 15% shows no distortion, blurring or ghosting with Twixtor Pro applied.

One thing I liked is that the workflow when moving from Final Cut Pro to Adobe After Effects was pretty much the same. You have the same modes to change and settings to configure.

Parameters in Adobe After Effects are manipulated in very much the same way as you would in Final Cut Pro.

I always make mention of a site’s tutorials and documentation for new users. There are several video tutorials to help you get started that used Twixtor Version 4, however, while some were quite helpful, I also found parts of them to be highly confusing. The first video tutorial provided a very good overview of the basic plug-in though I found, while understandable, the distorted audio to be a real annoyance. Another tutorial on speed ramping was divided in two parts, the first covered using Frames as the remapping mode. I found the narrator’s directions to be dizzying, however, when she switched over to remapping in speed mode, well, that section was much easier to follow. There were no video tutorials of any kind pertaining to Twixtor Pro’s considerably more advanced features or when working with Twixtor’s Vector in functions and, to be honest, I found the manuals for the Twixtor plug-ins to be so complicated in its language and presentation that they were really of no help at all and would certainly not be understood by a new editor. After having read a review of Twixtor Version 1 written in 2001, I noticed that the author had said approximately the same thing so I don’t expect that documentation will be improved anytime soon. Important to note that I did find several excellent video tutorials for using Twixtor in Adobe After Effects on YouTube that may be helpful to you. Notification of updates is done via the RE:Visions Facebook page and other major press releases. I would prefer that for those who bought a license for Twixtor that their registration info would be used so as to be notified of updates that way.

However, these failings do not take away from the fact that Twixtor really does its job very well. As I said before, I found that when creating a slow motion clip, it was better to apply Twixtor to a clip that did not have too much motion to it in the first place. Re:Vision’s Twixtor is not exactly inexpensive and they do need to write an easy to understand manual for all their versions, however, for those who must have the very best in slow motion and speed ramping effects, Twixtor will prove to produce more accurate in its motion estimation and object tracking with less artifacts where subjects are crossing the frame. With the majority of test clips I used, the results when speeding up a clip produced far less stutter and considerably smoother motion, for slow motion the results can be just stunning.

Twixtor FX Plug in for FCP-$329.95.
Twixtor for Adobe After Effects-$329.95.
Twixtor Pro for Adobe After Effects-$529.95.
Upgrades from prior versions-$82.49.
The Twixtor plug-in is available from RE:Vision Effects.

This review is by Steve Douglas, a certified Apple Pro for Final Cut Pro 7 and underwater videographer. A winner of the 1999 Pacific Coast Underwater Film Competition, 2003 IVIE competition, 2004 Los Angeles Underwater Photographic competition, and the prestigious 2005 International Beneath the Sea Film Competition, where he also won the Stan Waterman Award for Excellence in Underwater Videography and 'Diver of the Year', Steve was a safety diver on the feature film "The Deep Blue Sea", contributed footage to the Seaworld Park's Atlantis production, and productions for National Geographic and the History channels. Steve was a feature writer for Asian Diver Magazine and is one of the founding organizers of the San Diego UnderSea Film Exhibition. The Twixtor plug-in was provided free of charge for review purposes.

Mini review: Lightroom SoftProof plug-in :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Mini review: Lightroom SoftProof plug-in

A plug-in that plugs a gap in Adobe Lightroom's capabilities.

Posted: 18 December 2010 06:02 AM
Last Update: 18 December 2010 06:44 AM

Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Adam Hanlon ( adamhanlon )
Related Link: Lightroom Plugins

Mini review: SoftProof plug-in for Lightroom.
By Adam Hanlon.

The SoftProof plug-in screen.

When Adobe upgraded its popular photo management software Lightroom to version 3 earlier this year, one of the major feature requests was for the ability to soft proof. Soft proofing is a process that allows you to view images on screen, with the same profile applied to them that will be used during printing. The idea is that in a color-managed workflow, this should give the user a pretty clear idea of how the image will eventually look printed on paper using an ICC profile.

Typically you will be given ICC profiles with high-end printers, or perhaps generate them yourself using products like the Spyder or ColorMunki. Each printer will have different characteristics, which will be different again for each type of paper and ink you use. Online printers, even though many will say they request an sRGB colorspace, will also have different output for the same reason.

Hence many photographers value the ability to generate a snapshot of how an image will look before committing to expensive paper and ink.

Adobe did not deliver the ability to soft proof in Lightroom version 3 (as of version 3.3), but Lightroom Plugins has recently released an after-market plug-in that allows an image to be soft proofed from within Lightroom. Whilst the actual need for soft proofing will be debated amongst photographers for some time to come, this plug-in is the first serious attempt to provide this capability.

SoftProof is available as a trial download from the Lightroom Plugins site, and is a fairly straightforward installation using the MSI into Windows machines. Installing on Apples is slightly more complicated, but no more so that copying and pasting the plug-in file into Lightroom’s “modules” folder. The download also incorporates a pdf manual for the plug-in.

Once installed, the plug-in is accessed (on a Mac) via the “Plug-in Extras” menu. On a windows machine, it is accessible via a keyboard shortcut. With a picture highlighted in Lightroom, the plug-in opens into a new window. By inputting the computers display profile and the required printer ICC profile, SoftProof generates an image showing how the picture will look on paper. There is the option to either display the original image alongside, or just the soft-proof.

Other options include the ability to compensate black points and simulate paper white. If these options are unchecked, SoftProof can also provide out of gamut warnings.

SoftProof profile options.

In practice, SoftProof proved easy to install and use. The lack of keyboard shortcut for access to it (on my Mac) is not ideal however. I am assured that this is a Mac OS problem, and hence not something the plug-in developers can remedy. I have quite a few plug-ins installed in Lightroom, and as SoftProof was the last one installed, it falls to the bottom of the list. This means several mouse clicks and then a scroll through the other items on the list in order to access it.

I am in the process of printing some images with my Epson R1800, and have in general noticed that it tends to darken my images, when compared with the on-screen image. It is very interesting to note that when SoftProof renders an image for the R1800, they also seem darker than the original. I see this as being proof of the plug-ins accuracy at predicting how the image will look when printed. When printing, the SoftProof screen image seems very close to the printed one, certainly far closer then the usual rendering in Lightroom’s print module.

The other criticism relates to this: Once the plug in has opened, it must be closed and the image corrected in Lightroom, before opening it to soft-proof again. There is no ability to alter the print previews dynamically without closing and re-opening the plug-in. This is somewhat tedious in practice, especially if you need to make multiple corrections. It would be nice to be able to keep the soft proof image open, and for corrections to be applied to it as they are added.

There is no doubt that SoftProof serves to plug an important gap in Lightroom’s existing capabilities. Not all photographers will agree on the need for soft proofing in order to get faithful print results, but for those that do, this plug-in offers a workable solution. Bear in mind that it will only work reliably when used in conjunction with a color-managed printing pipeline. Despite the practical issues listed, SoftProof is a great tool for photographers wanting to print images. I have not used it to proof images for use with online printing houses, perhaps if people do, they could add feedback to this review.

This review was carried out using my personal purchased copy of SoftProof. The plug-in is available from Lightroom Plugins, and a trial version is offered. This limits the output to low-resolution images. The unlocked version currently costs UKP10 (approx USD16).

Alex Mustard reviews MarineLife Keywords in UwP 50 :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Alex Mustard reviews MarineLife Keywords in UwP 50

Posted: 10 September 2009 04:23 PM
Last Update: 11 September 2009 10:07 PM
discuss in forums
Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Eric Cheng ( echeng )
Related Link: UwP Mag

Underwater Photography Magazine (UwP), a free PDF magazine, has published a review of MarineLife Keywords written by marine biologist and award-winning photographer Alexander Mustard. The review can be found in their 50th issue, which is available as a free download from their website. Alex says:

The list includes the genus and species of 12,000 species, including over 4,000 fish, 4,000 invertebrates, and all known marine turtles, rays, skates, marine reptiles, and marine mammals… The first thing I did was to try to find any absentees. It is not easy. The coverage is fantastic…

... keywording is an essential part of workflow for anyone who supplies their images to photo stock libraries. MLKL was built for these tasks and having tasted it I could never give it up.

It is often said that time is money. I can’t think of many other products, designed for underwater photographers, which will save you as much time for so little money. A highly recommended purchase.

Alex likes it! :)

Canopus EDIUS Pro 4 Review :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Canopus EDIUS Pro 4 Review

Posted: 28 October 2006 05:50 PM
Last Update: 28 October 2006 07:20 PM

Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Matt Segal ( segal3 )
Related Link: EDIUS 4 Review

Wetpixel video moderator Paul Wags (wagsy) has written a review of his impressions of Canopus’ EDIUS Pro 4. EDIUS is a Windows PC-based nonlinear video editing program that can edit both DV and HDV.

The main reason for switching [from Premiere Pro and Aspect HD] is that I can do realtime-on-the-fly conversion to the Canopus HQ codec, and the keyframeable color correction and slow-motion in real-time is perfect for our underwater footage.

Continue reading for Paul’s review of the EDIUS software package... 

Image Tank G2 Portable Storage :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Image Tank G2 Portable Storage

Posted: 08 September 2003 04:00 PM
Last Update: 25 February 2005 06:55 PM
2 comment(s)
Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: James Wiseman
Review Item: Image Tank G2 Portable Storage

I decided to order an Image Tank G2 to replace my “Old reliable” Image Tank. The reasons I thought now would be a good time to upgrade are that the g2 has an internal rechargeable battery, the ability to confirm the number of files backed up, the LCD tells and usb2.0 connectity to my pc. The fact that the Image Tank G2 can also be used as a portable USB2.0 hard drive is yet another reason.

This shot shows a comparison of the older Image Tank on the left to the G2 on the Right

I already had a 40gig hard drive, so I opted to get the “bare bones” Image Tank G2 without a drive. Mounting a hard drive is super-easy and my drive is already formattee, so I gigured it would be a breeze. I ordered my kit from: www.insidecomputers.com and selected 2-day Fedex shipping for a very reasonable rate. To my surprise the kit showed up the next day and I was a very happy customer.

Here’s what was included:

Image Tank G2

AC converter

Car Cigarette Lighter Adapter

Faux Leather Carrying Case

Driver Disk

Instruction Book

The G2 no longer has multiple slots – they have adopted a CF Card Only stance, which is fine with me.

Mounting the hard drive was easy and I only needed to loosen four screws to do it. Here’s what the unit looks like inside:

The G2 with the backplate removed. USB2 connection at lower center.

Simply snap in the hard drive, replace the cover, and tighten the screws to have a complete unit.

The assembled unit

If your drive isn’t formatted, simply power up the Image Tank G2 and connect it to your PC via the USB cable. It doesn’t matter if your computer is USB1 or USB2 – either will work. Your PC should detect a device and you can “right click” to format it. The old Image Tank required the hard drive to be formatted FAT32. I didn’t reformat it, so I’m not sure about the G2 - hopefully it is NTFS compliant now.

Using the G2 is easy.

Backup photos: Plug in your memory card and push the EXE button to copy your files. The G2 will create a subdirectory for you. When the download is complete it will tell you how many files have been copied, so you can doublecheck you got everything.

Copy to Computer: Plug in the USB cable and your computer should auto-detect the drive as a USB Mass Storage Device. Then you can access it to copy the photos or the subdirectories (if you have more than one image backup) to your home PC

Erase Card: I don’t know why you’d want to do this, but you can erase all the folders off your card using the G2

Erase Subdirectory: If you have duplicate items or after a backup to your PC, you can erase the photos on the G2 independently – without having to hook it up to a computer.

Summary of Nice Features:

  • LCD Shows remaining space on your HD in megabytes

  • Confirmation of files backed up

  • Ability to delete files from the G2 while untethered

  • USB2.0 connectivity

  • Small size and long lasting internal battery

  • Battery remaining indicator in the LCD

  • 44 downloads of a 256MB card on one charge.

If you decide to get your Image Tank G2 without a hard drive, here is a link to a popular store with notebook hard drives for sale:

search.dell.com

From time to time they have 10% to 20% off sales and you can get some good deals. Other recommended vendors are Newegg.com and compgeeks.com

Conclusion: For the price the Image Tank G2 is highly recommended for travelers who like to shoot a lot and don’t want to carry a computer.

Vosonic X’S Drive :: Wetpixel.com

ADVERTISEMENT - LOG IN/REGISTER TO HIDE

Vosonic X’S Drive

6-in-1 Portable EZ Storage

Posted: 19 November 2002 04:00 PM
Last Update: 25 February 2005 06:55 PM
1 comment(s)
Categories: ReviewsComputing [home]
Author: Eric Cheng
Review Item: Vosonic X'S Drive

The Vosonic X'S-Drive VP-2030 was thoroughly reviewed by Steve's Digicams not long ago. If you are interested in a full review, please check it out! I purchased the drive from the Computer Geeks, for $87 + shipping, and obtained a 20gb Toshiba 2.5" IDE drive for roughly $80 (40gb drives can be found for around $120, shipped, if you look hard enough).

I'm finding that the drive works as advertised. It's small, and it works with nearly every commonly used media type -- without PC card adapters! However, a serious design flaw risks making the drive virtually unusable without AC power. When I received the drive, I removed the packaging and turned it over to remove the screws on the bottom. When I flipped the drive back over, I noticed that it had been powered on. It turns out that neither the "power" nor "copy" buttons are recessed, so any flat surface that comes in contact with the top of the drive will effectively toggle the power on and off. Simple flipping the drive over and placing it upside-down on a table often toggles drive power.

I can imagine packing the drive in my bag and arriving at a destination only to find that the battery was dead. In practice, this probably wouldn't happen, since the drive powers itself off after 25 seconds if you don't start a copy, but it is still disconcerting to know that the hard disk could be powered on and spinning during transport.

I walked over to the neighborhood hardware store, picked up a couple of nylon washers, and used epoxy to attach them around each of the buttons:

It's not pretty, but it is now much harder to accidentally turn the drive on while handling it. Even with the washers preventing the buttons from being pushed accidentally, I found that if you apply firm pressure to the case area around the power button, the drive still turns on and off. This shouldn't be a problem when the drive is placed in the included padded case, unless you have packed other items pushing firmly against it.

Even with this design flaw, it's still a good deal for $87. :)

Formatting the hard disk while installed in the X'S Drive unit turns out to be a bit more complicated than the manual might suggest. The manual says that the drive cannot be formatted with Windows 2000, but I found that I couldn't format it through Windows XP, either. I've also received e-mail from more tha none person saying that they had problems formatting the through Windows XP. It seems that you must have a Windows 98/SE/ME machine handy for X'S Drive formatting. Otherwise, you will have to format the drive through other means (e.g. hooking it up to a notebook computer, which is what I had to do).

Eric Cheng

-- From user "woody," on Wetpixel forums:

I'm back from my Red Sea trip and had an opportunity to test the X-Drive. I use a CP995 with a 256Mb card, so I get to store some 250-300 shots taken at the highest possible JPEG quality.

The way I worked was like this. Once the card was getting full, I trasferred the images to the drive. Not being that confident that all was working OK (I had only received the drive the day before I left on the trip, and there is no way to view the images on the drive), I left the "keepers" stored on the camera's memory, and deleted the rest to make room. I did this two or three times, each time obviously having to be a bit more selective. In all I shot some 500 images, not all u/w.

Once back home, I transferred the images, but aaargh, I discovered that a few jpegs (10-15) which were stored on the drive were corrupt. Luckily I did not lose anything serious, as all the images I thought were the better ones were still on the camera.

I dug around a bit and discovered that the problem is a known one. Basically there is a bug in the drive's firmware that kicks in when images are fragmented on the camera memory. I have emailed Vosonic for the firmware fix, and I'll keep you updated with the way this progresses.

The irony is that had I formatted the memory card each time I transferred, I would not have experienced the problem! On the other hand, no harm done luckily, and now I know about the problem I can try to get it fixed.

Apart from this, the little machine worked "as advertised"!

More information:

Review at Steve's Digicams
X'S-Drive website
NEW Version 2 X'S Drive information at DPReview.com (USB 2.0)

Page 1 of 1 [ ]

Comment(s):
  1. Wish I was there....I love your Jawfish spitting sand shot....what a catch

    Karl

    Posted by kdietz on 07/26 at 12:54 PM
  2. Great results over there and what a storm. Did it even dry up that day?

    Posted by DuikKees on 07/26 at 11:11 PM
  3. Whoops! Shouldn’t “In her day, the Alice H was an old cargo boat” be “In her day, the Hilma Hooker was an old cargo boat”?

    Looks like you guys are having a blast! :)

    Posted by NitroLiq on 07/28 at 06:40 AM
  4. The ‘DID YOU KNOW...GUESS WHO IT IS’ insert question was way too easy.  The photo of those rippling biceps was a dead give away of Berkeley’s former football career.  Maybe you guys can take up a collection and get him some new booties. The picture of him going down the ladder (naked toes and all) still hurts my eyes.

    Posted by dmoss on 07/28 at 01:04 PM
  5. Wow- Pauline’s underwater photo looking up at the dive boat bow is excellent!

    James

    Posted by James Wiseman on 07/28 at 01:28 PM
  6. I so wish I was there!  Great shots, looks like a lot a fun....

    Posted by Reefkeep on 07/28 at 04:37 PM
  7. We have the world’s best photographers all right here on one website and I am glad to be a part...if we could all be together for one meeting, we would definitely need a bigger island!! Great stuff here kids, keep up the good work....john

    Posted by carib-blu on 07/29 at 04:46 PM
  8. p.s. thanks for the purple crown sea goddess Pauline!....have only seen one other here in cayman!Good find!

    Posted by carib-blu on 07/29 at 04:54 PM
  9. that group shot of everyone and their gear is probably a crooked TSA/AA baggage persons wet dream!  no wonder we dont have a shootout in miami or san juan.

    Posted by nitteo on 08/01 at 01:56 PM

You must be logged in to post comments. Please log in or register (it's free!) and come back to this page to leave your comment.

<< Back to main

Login | Register

WETPIXEL QUARTERLY

SEARCH

JOIN US

Register now to join our active community. It's completely free!

Join the Wetpixel mailing list and receive regular updates about new articles, trips, etc.

Join Team Wetpixel and support this site!

Follow Wetpixel on Twitter. We like Twitter.

WORKFLOW

MarineLife Keywords
Simplify your marine wildlife keywording!

ARTICLE ARCHIVES

ADVERTISEMENTS

POTW CONTEST

by EspenRekdal
last contest - potw home

SPONSORS

http://uwimaging.com http://gateshousings.com http://marinecamera.com http://www.nocturnallights.com/content.php?56-Keldan-Lights-Distributor http://reefphotovideo.com http://solmarv.com/ http://www.divequest-travel.com http://www.watershot.com http://www.camerasunderwater.co.uk/ http://www.nauticamusa.com http://backscatter.com http://divephotoguide.com http://ikelite.com