Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Altered Images - opinions on which is better
Bushy
post Dec 28 2004, 05:07 PM
Post #1


Clownfish
*
Member
Posts: 29
Perth, Western Australia


okay here are some images in there original state and then under them is the altered image. Which is preferred the more natural look or the altered image? Being very new to this whole Uw photography stuff i'm not sure which way to go.

When i get a spectacular photo i'll enter it in the POTW...don't hold your breath though...might take me some time.

Original


Altered



Original


Altered


Original


Altered


Original


Altered
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
craig
post Dec 29 2004, 05:50 AM
Post #2


Full Moon Rising
Group Icon
Super Mod
Posts: 2,826
Austin, TX



This is somewhat a matter or taste, especially the second one where you've removed background material. I wouldn't describe these as alterations, though, since it's really just adjustment in presentation. To me, alterations are when you clone out signification features or move (or even merge) subject matter in the frame. Is cropping an alteration? This is just arguing language. The changes you've made might be made in camera if the camera was smart enough and photographers do this all the time.

To answer the question, though, I lean toward the altered versions in all cases, especially #3. I like removing the background in #2 but could see someone preferring it left in. I still prefer the enhanced contrast on the subject in #2.


--
I love it when a plan comes together.
- Col. John "Hannibal" Smith

------
Nikon, Seatool, Nexus, Inon
My Galleries
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
scubamarli
post Dec 30 2004, 11:41 PM
Post #3


Great Hammerhead
****
Industry
Posts: 831
North Vancouver, B.C. Canada



Well, I would tend to agree. You seem to have done a lot of sharpening, which looks great on the web, but may be a bit much for printing, however. My suggestion is to work more on composing the shot instead of relying on post-production. Move your subject off-center, and try interesting angles. Wouldn't you rather spend your time underwater instead in front of a computer? (Gosh, where am I right now?!)
Cheers,
Marli


--
Marli Wakeling
Nikon D200, D40X, A200 Aquatica housing, 60mm, 105mm, 18-200 VR, Sigma 10-20mm, Sigma 15mm FE, Sigma 28-80 adapted for full time macro, hacked Canon A570IS in Fisher-Price box, Sea & Sea strobes, ULCS and StiX arms, empty bank account
www.marliwakeling.com
Duct tape is like the force. It has a light side, a dark side, and it holds the universe together. ~Carl Zwanzig
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Bushy
post Jan 3 2005, 10:57 PM
Post #4


Clownfish
*
Member
Posts: 29
Perth, Western Australia


Thanks guys appreciate your comments and will definately take your advice on board re: moving the subject off centre and different angles etc. These were only my second lot of pics ever taken so i have heaps to learn and hope to get some really good pics before too long.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
scorpio_fish
post Jan 6 2005, 01:34 PM
Post #5


Orca
*****
Industry
Posts: 1,233
Dallas, TX



In all cases, the altered versions are better. The camera captures an image based on the settings. It is not "natural", nor is it necessarily the way we see it with our eyes at the time. Making post capture adjustments fits the word natural better. Most people don't realize that prints made from roll of film are adjusted, too. Well, maybe they don't remove backscatter. smile.gif

Actually, a properly sharpened image for a print will look over sharpened on a computer screen, depending on the size of the print.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
herbko
post Jan 6 2005, 02:10 PM
Post #6


Herbzilla
Group Icon
Super Mod
Posts: 2,126
Northern California


I think the altered version of #2 is worst. You clipped some highlights and made it look more overexposed.


--
Herb Ko http://herbko.net
Canon 5D; Aquatica housing; 2 Inon Z220 strobes; Canon 100mm macro, 17-40mm ; Sigma 15mm FE, 24mm macro, 50mm macro
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Alex_Mustard
post Jan 10 2005, 01:03 AM
Post #7


The Doctor
Group Icon
Super Mod
Posts: 6,705
Hampshire, England



I prefer the altered images. Digital cameras, particularly DSLRS tend to shoot flat images - as you can always increase contrast afterwards, but you can't get detail back. So most digital iimages look best with a bit of a contrast boost. Particular for screen viewing.

The amount of contrast/punch applied to the images does vary between cameras. And certain cameras are well known for producing better JPGS straight from the camera - the Fuji S2 for example. Last summer I ran the digital category of British Society of Underwater Photographers' on the day Splash In competition. As it was the first year for digital we decided, for the sake of simplicity, to not allow any digital manipulation to images. They had to be straight from the camera. What was interesting was that digicam images were inherently more punchy than the DSLR images (from D100s, D70s, S2s, and 10Ds) and a digicam image came 2nd overall as a result.
http://www.bsoup.org/Splash/2004/S2004.html

I think that it is important to consider than some post processing is just part of the process of digital underwater photography. But that is never an excuse for not trying to get the image as good as possible when you are in the water.

Alex


--
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post

Reply to this topicStart new topic

 

RSS Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 09.Feb.10-08:06

Wetpixel Quarterly
 

Join Team Wetpixel

Subscribe to newsletter

Follow Wetpixel on Twitter. We like Twitter.

MarineLife Keywords. Simplify your marine wildlife keywording!

SPONSORS

http://uwimaging.com http://gateshousings.com http://marinecamera.com http://www.inon.jp/ http://reefphotovideo.com http://aquatica.ca http://www.amphibico.com http://www.aditech-uw.com http://www.h2ophotopros.com http://digideep.com http://backscatter.com http://divephotoguide.com http://seaandsea.com http://ikelite.com

ADVERTISEMENTS

DiveFilm Video Podcast